Lifting Analysis Case Study

Lifting Lug and Trunnion FEA for a Heavy Tube Bundle Lift

ENA2 built detailed finite element models of the lifting lugs and trunnions on a heavy tube bundle, checked them at three positions through a horizontal-to-vertical lift under factored lifting loads, and developed strengthening for the overstressed regions in the existing design.

Case Study Overview

The Challenge: Rotating a Heavy Tube Bundle from Horizontal to Vertical

The lifting lugs and trunnions of a heavy tube bundle needed a structural assessment for lifting and rotation from horizontal to vertical. ENA2 assessed the existing designs with finite element analysis as part of its cranes, lifting and fall arrest systems engineering work.

As the bundle rotates, the load on each lug changes direction and out-of-plane loading appears, so a check at a single position may not capture the governing case. The designs were therefore assessed at several lifting positions under factored lifting loads.

Assessment Workflow

Engineering Approach: Lifting Lug Analysis at 0°, 45° and 90°

  1. 01 Finite element models

    ENA2 built detailed finite element models of the lifting lugs, the trunnions and the regions where they attach to the bundle.

  2. 02 Three lifting positions

    The system was evaluated at 0°, 45° and 90° lifting positions. Loads were applied to represent bearing contact between the lifting components and the lifting pins or trunnions.

  3. 03 Factored loads and stress evaluation

    The analysis incorporated factored lifting loads in accordance with ASME BTH-1. It evaluated stress distributions in the lug plates, attachment regions, trunnion pipe and supporting components.

Finite element models of the lifting lug and trunnion on a heavy tube bundle
Finite element models of the lifting lug and trunnion.
Engineering Outcome

Challenge, Engineering Approach & Result

01

Challenge

Lugs and trunnions on a heavy tube bundle had to be verified for a lift that rotates the bundle from horizontal to vertical, with the load distribution changing at every angle.

02

Engineering Approach

ENA2 built detailed finite element models of the lugs and trunnions and evaluated them at 0°, 45° and 90° under factored lifting loads in accordance with ASME BTH-1, with bearing contact at the lifting pins and trunnions.

03

Result

The FEA identified overstressed regions in the existing lifting lugs and trunnion pipe. ENA2 developed targeted strengthening that reduced stresses to within the applicable material yield limits for the specified lifting conditions.

Strengthening measures developed from the FEA results

The stress plots show the existing lug at two lifting positions. Based on these results, ENA2 developed:

  • Reinforcing pads around the lug holes
  • An increased trunnion pipe wall thickness

Both measures target the regions that were overstressed in the existing design.

Von Mises stress in the existing lifting lug at the 45 degree lifting position
Von Mises stress in the existing lifting lug at the 90 degree lifting position
Stress distributions in the existing lifting lug at the 45° and 90° lifting positions, before strengthening.
Practical Guidance

What This Means If You Are Planning a Heavy Lift

  • Check lifting attachments for the specific lift arrangement planned. If the component is rotated, include representative positions through the rotation, not only the starting position.
  • Consider out-of-plane loading on lugs when the lift angle changes.
  • If an existing lug or trunnion is overstressed, assess targeted local strengthening as an option.
  • Ask for the check to cover the lug, the trunnion and the attachment regions to the component, not only the lug plate.

For finite element analysis of other equipment, see our mechanical FEA services and stress analysis services.

FAQ

Lifting Lug and Trunnion FEA FAQ

How do you check lifting lugs and trunnions for a heavy tube bundle lift?

In this project, ENA2 checked the lifting lugs and trunnions with detailed finite element models evaluated at 0°, 45° and 90° lifting positions. Loads were applied to represent bearing contact at the lifting pins or trunnions. Stress distributions were evaluated in the lug plates, attachment regions, trunnion pipe and supporting components.

Why analyze several lifting angles and out-of-plane loading?

In general, the direction of load on a lifting attachment changes as the component rotates, so a single position may not represent the whole lift. In this project, for lifting and rotation from horizontal to vertical, the lifting system was subjected to varying load distributions at different lifting angles, including out-of-plane loading.

What can be done if FEA shows an existing lifting lug or trunnion is overstressed?

One option is targeted local strengthening. In this project, ENA2 developed reinforcing pads around the lug holes and an increased trunnion pipe wall thickness. The analysis showed that these strengthened designs reduced stresses to within the applicable material yield limits for the specified lifting conditions. In general, the right measure depends on the design of each lug and trunnion.

Which lifting standard was referenced in this analysis?

The analysis incorporated factored lifting loads in accordance with ASME BTH-1. The design category, service class and factors used are not published in this case study.

What information should I send for a lifting lug or trunnion analysis?

Send the inputs that apply to your lift, typically the component weight and center of gravity, drawings of the lugs, trunnions and attachments, material information, the lift arrangement and angles to check, pin, shackle and rigging details, and any lifting standard or owner requirement that applies. Scope and schedule are confirmed per project after reviewing the inputs.

Tell us about your project

Send a short description and we will propose a scope for your study. You do not need every input ready before you contact us.

What happens next

  1. An engineer reviews your request.
  2. We contact you to schedule a meeting with the engineer or engineering manager who would lead your project, usually within one business day.
  3. Before any project starts, you receive a written scope and quote.
P.Eng. (Canada) or P.E. (USA) stamped reports on request.

Prefer to talk? Call +1 403-910-5957 or message us on WhatsApp. After our first reply, send drawings and models to info@ena2.com.

Scroll to Top